About Us

Family Dentist Pagosa Springs

30+ Years Serving You

Best Dentists Pagosa Springs CO Dr Jordan Rutherford DDS

Hello, welcome to Pagosa Smiles
Dental Practice

Your comfort & satisfaction are Pagosa Smiles’ top priorities.

Our dental office team has extensive experience providing family dentistry to the Pagosa Springs community. Our experienced staff will provide you caring support and individualized treatments that will make your dental experience comfortable and anxiety-free.

Best Dentists Pagosa Springs See Pagosa Peak Summit in the Distance

Dr. Jordan Rutherford, DDS

General Dentist & Doctorate in Dental Surgery

Best Rated Dentist in Pagosa Springs CO Pagosa Smiles
Top Rated Teenager Youth Dentist in Pagosa Springs CO Pagosa Smiles
Top Rated Family Dentist in Pagosa Springs CO Pagosa Smiles
Best Dentists Near Me Pagosa Springs CO Pagosa Smiles
Top Rated Teenager Youth Dentist in Pagosa Springs CO Pagosa Smiles

Dentist in Pagosa Springs for over 30 Years

New Technology / Air Abrasion

New technology has given us another gift in the form of AIR ABRASION. This instrument allows us to gently remove decay in a very precise manner while preserving the majority of healthy tooth structure. For small cavities this means up to 10 times the amount of healthy tooth saved over the old “drill” and silver fillings. The cleaned cavity is then filled with a tooth colored composite.

The best part is that if the cavities are found early, before they get big, they can be painlessly filled without the annoying numbness we used to associate with dental fillings. The procedure feels like air being blown onto the tooth. In fact that is exactly what it is: a stream of air carries a fine powder against the cavity which wears away the decay.

Get Your Teeth Checked at min. 2x/Yr

The important thing to remember is to get your teeth checked early and often (at least twice a year) so that cavities can be found when they are small enough for this revolutionary new procedure.

No Fear Dentistry

We believe that everyone deserves a life of pain free dental health and a beautiful smile. We have dedicated our lives to helping our patients achieve that goal. Our motto is:

“The art of dentistry: gently restoring the health that God created.”

We do just about everything from crowns and fillings to root canals and implants.

Insurance Providers

Insurance Providers we currently accept.

  • Cigna
  • Delta Dental
  • Anthem
  • Blue Cross Blue Shield
  • Aflac
Lucrecia T. profile picture
Lucrecia T.
17:18 30 Jan 26
Dr. Rutherford and his staff are amazing-kind, smart, and accommodating! I had fast braces and the process was quick and tolerable. I would recommended Pagosa Smiles over and over to anyone looking for dental care an/or considering braces.
nathaniel W. profile picture
nathaniel W.
15:21 29 Jan 26
I had an outstanding experience with Pagosa Smiles while I was working in Pagosa Springs helping build the Snowball Water Treatment Plant and actively serving in the Marine Corps Reserve.

In November, in observance of Veterans Day, Pagosa Smiles offered free dental work for veterans and service members. After spending a long stretch working in the mountains, I was overdue for dental care, and their timing could not have been better. The team fit me in right when I needed it most.

From the moment I walked in, I was treated like family. McKenna, LeAnn, and the dentist were welcoming, professional, and genuinely caring. They examined and cleaned my teeth and also extracted a tooth that was out of place and causing me significant pain. Everything was explained clearly, and they made sure I was comfortable the entire time.

Being thanked for my service is something I truly appreciate. Being shown that thanks through action means the world to me. The team at Pagosa Smiles is a pillar of the community and a great example of hardworking Americans doing meaningful work for the people around them.

After receiving care here, I recommended Pagosa Smiles to everyone I worked with and everyone I know in the area. I continue to recommend them to anyone and everyone in need of dental work who wants a welcoming, professional, and compassionate environment.

Absolutely top-notch care from an even better team.
Dee S. profile picture
Dee S.
19:55 28 Jan 26
Excellent experience, service, and results.
Gabriela Q. profile picture
Gabriela Q.
17:02 28 Jan 26
Friendly staff, clean office, and great care. Always a positive experience. Highly recommend!
Payton M. profile picture
Payton M.
15:45 28 Jan 26
Needed a clean before losing my insurance and they were very helpful.
Jerbear G profile picture
Jerbear G
15:25 28 Jan 26
I have been coming to Dr Rutherford's office since early 2004 and have always been very happy with the entire staff. I continue to be happy with the services and financial help that is available as well as the superior and special customer service.
Denise F. profile picture
Denise F.
12:31 20 Jan 26
Focused on efficiency! Talented staff from the door to followup. Skilled in their areas. Been my dentist since we moved here. Quality!
Sydney B. profile picture
Sydney B.
16:14 16 Jan 26
Great team! They explained things very well laid out all my option. Great experience

Your comfort and satisfaction at Pagosa Smiles' family dentistry is our top priority. Our dental office team has extensive experience providing family dentistry to the Pagosa Springs community and surrounding areas.

DAYS HOURS
Monday CLOSED
Tuesday 8AM-5PM
Wednesday 8AM-5PM
Thursday 8AM-5PM
Friday 8AM-5PM
Saturday CLOSED
Saturday CLOSED
Copyright © 2026 Pagosa Smiles. All Rights Reserved.